Tom Dienhart, BTN.com Senior Writer, September 2, 2012
A.J. McCarron passes two yards to Michael Williams for a touchdown. A.J. McCarron passes 51 yards to DeAndrew White for a touchdown. Eddie Lacy rushes nine yards for a touchdown. And just like that, Alabama was ahead, 21-0, over Michigan. And there still were two minutes left ? in the first quarter.
It was one of those nights for Michigan in its big showdown with Alabama in Cowboys Stadium in Arlington, Texas, as this game was over before the massive 2,100-inch video board had even warmed up.
The college football world had waited months-at times this summer, it felt like years–for this game to officially take the lid off the 2012 season.
Not only was this going to be the most anticipated game of the first weekend of the season. But it also was going to be a chance for the Big Ten to earn some street cred vs. the nation's biggest, baddest and best conference-the SEC, winners of the last six national titles.
The Big Ten? It has 1.5 national titles (AP, UPI or BCS) since 1969.
But, instead of showing America that it was ready to stand toe-to-toe with the nation's elite, Michigan's showing in a 41-14 defeat to the Crimson Tide only further cemented the images of both the SEC (lynchpin) and Big Ten (wannabe).
Not even suspended Wolverine running back Fitz Toussaint would have made a difference tonight in Cowboys Stadium in what was the worst season-opening loss in school annals. Michigan would have had to summon a collection of its past All-Americans to stay on the field with this Alabama team on this night.
Who are we trying to kid? The Wolverines had no business being on the same field as this Crimson Tide team, which has won two out of the last three national championships (2009 and 2011) and just happens to be the hottest team in America.
Alabama out gained Michigan, 430 yards to 268, racing to a 31-7 halftime lead. The Crimson Tide imposed their will on the Wolverines, rushing for 231 yards and limiting Michigan to 68 on the ground while forcing the Wolverines into three turnovers.
The Wolverines? They haven't even won the Big Ten since-Are you ready for this?-2004. This is a Michigan program that remains a work-in-progress.
Yes, I know all about the 11-2 mark last year in Brady Hoke's debut season. I know all about the wins over Notre Dame, Nebraska, Ohio State and then Virginia Tech in the Sugar Bowl-among others–in 2011.
[BTN.com: See who won Week 1 Big Ten game balls]
But that wasn't a dominating Michigan team. This wasn't a team that truly crushed any foe. Heck, Michigan isn't even the best team in its own state. Wolverine fans may not like hearing that, but it's true.
Now, I think Michigan is pointed on an upward track. I trust what Hoke is doing and think he can get the program back to where it was under Lloyd Carr, who won five Big Ten crowns and a share of the 1997 national championship.
But, it will take time. Remember: Hoke inherited a hot mess from the disastrous Rich Rodriguez tenure that seems like a three-year bad dream after it produced a 15-22 overall mark and 6-18 record in the Big Ten. There were dubious home losses to the likes of Northwestern, Illinois, Purdue and Toledo. TOLEDO!!!
Worst of all: Rodriguez got this proud program on NCAA probation for the first time ever. And that, ladies and gentlemen, hurt more than any losses to Ohio State. And, there were three of those under Rich Rod.
But, Hoke began turning the page on that ugly recent history last season. No doubt, he has done a lot of good in a short period of time. However, tonight was a painful reminder that the process will take more time. All good things take time.
Saban went 7-6 his first season at Alabama in 2007, needing a 30-24 win over Colorado in the Independence bowl to finish over .500. Earlier in that season, there was an utterly humiliating 21-14 home loss to Louisiana-Monroe. And there also was a numbing 17-12 defeat at Mississippi State.
Again, my point: Saban and Bama had to do some suffering and building before enjoying the fruits of their labor. Consider this loss tonight to be part of the suffering-part of the building process-for Hoke and Michigan.
If it's any consolation to Michigan fans, they surely remember what Saban and Bama did to Michigan State in the Capital One Bowl after the 2010 season, when the Tide whipped the Spartans, 49-7. Honestly, it wasn't really that close, with Bama totaling 546 yards and MSU 171-with minus-48 on the ground. Look where Michigan State is now. Michigan will get there.
Hoke already is recruiting well. His 2011 class ranked No. 21 in the nation by Rivals.com; his 2012 class ranked No. 7. And this year's haul currently sits No. 7.
Despite this loss, Michigan still can win the Legends Division, it still can win the Big Ten. The Wolverines have Air Force and UMass next; then comes a game at Notre Dame. Michigan needs to move past tonight and focus on tomorrow.
Better days are ahead. Trust me.
|BTN.com senior writer Tom Dienhart is a veteran sports journalist who covers Big Ten football and men's basketball for BTN.com and BTN TV. Find him on Twitter and Facebook, read all of his work at btn.com/tomdienhart, and subscribe to his posts via RSS. Also, send questions to his weekly mailbag using the form below and read all of his previous answers in his reader mailbag section.|
And if you want to leave a comment on this post, use the box below. All comments need to be approved by a moderator.