Mailbag: Big Ten stadium list sparks debate

It’s time of the week for me to reach into my mailbag. Some good correspondence this week, as my Big Ten stadium rankings seemed to rankle many people and drive a few debates.

Remember that you can always email me on this page, or find me on Twitter (@BTNTomDienhart). Keep those cards and letters coming. Football is right around the corner.

I read your stadium rankings. Here are mine: Beaver Stadium (Penn State) 2. The Big House (Michigan) 3. The Horseshoe (Ohio State) 4. Memorial Stadium (Nebraska) 5. Camp Randall (Wisconsin). – Ace

Nice list! The entire exercise is very subjective, obviously. Things I considered when doing mine: intimidation; aesthetics; tradition; noise. I think your top five is on target. I do think Spartan Stadium is one the cusp. The place can be tough to play in; ditto for Iowa’s Kinnick Stadium.

I think Michigan’s Big House rivals any Big Ten stadium when it comes to volume. Clearly, you were not there two years back for the night game vs. Notre Dame. The Big House was shaking!  Michigan Stadium is clearly better than Beaver stadium. The other top three are a toss-up, I agree. – Ryan

Yes, I may have been unfair in knocking the volume and loudness level of the Big House. The place has cranked up the volume in recent years. No doubt, winning makes fans cheer louder and more often. The Big House is just a cavernous sea of people that can swallow up the opposition. Very big, bold and intimidating.

I grew up in Central Ohio and am a traditionalist. I wonder how much schools like Ohio State, Notre Dame, TTUN (That School Up North) balance tradition and catering to recruits when you see these special uniforms every season? I personally hate them but understand why recruits might not. – J.C.

Good questions. But the consensus is that schools have these alternate unis to appeal to recruits, as you say. Like you, I don’t like most of them. And it seems like we’ve hit the saturation point, with schools seemingly trying to out-do each other with one outrageous design after another. When is enough enough? And, honestly: Do kids REALLY base a decision on what a school’s uniforms look like? It seems like an awfully shallow and flawed way to pick a school. It would be like buying a car because you liked the cup holders. Come on.

I’m glad that Ohio State is the only one in the Big Ten that has a good offense. Really? Please, get off the Buckeye bandwagon. They haven’t done anything yet. – Scott

Well, Urban Meyer did go 12-0 last year in his first season. That wasn’t too bad. And OSU has more recently won Big Ten and national titles than Michigan. BTN.com is even-handed in its coverage of all teams, I think, trying to spread the wealth. Yes, we had a Q&A with Ohio State offensive coordinator Tom Herman.

But the week before, we had one with Michigan offensive coordinator Al Borges. We give as much love to Michigan as we do to Ohio State.

Why do you think Northwestern’s non-conference schedule is more difficult than Ohio State’s?

You’re referring to my list here. Each team plays Cal, so that’s a wash. Look at each team’s foes. Ohio State: Buffalo (4-8 MAC); San Diego State (9-4 MWC, 1-0 vs. top 25); Florida A&M (4-7 FCS, 0-1 vs. top 25). Northwestern: Syracuse (8-5 BE, 1-2 vs. top 25); Western Michigan (4-8 MAC) Maine (5-6 FCS).

The rankings aren’t based solely on how schools did last year; some projection is used. First off, NU plays two schools from power leagues in Cal and Syracuse; OSU plays one in Cal. Second, NU’s FCS foe (Maine) is traditionally better then Ohio State’s (FAMU). Ditto NU’s MAC foe. Western Michigan is usually always better than Buffalo. So, there you. Maybe my gap between the two shouldn’t have been as great—but no doubt in my mind NU has the tougher non-con schedule.

***

About Tom Dienhart BTN.com senior writer Tom Dienhart is a veteran sports journalist who covers Big Ten football and men’s basketball for BTN.com and BTN TV. Find him on Twitter and Facebook, read all of his work at btn.com/tomdienhart, and subscribe to his posts via RSS. Also, send questions to his weekly mailbag using the form below and read all of his previous answers in his reader mailbag section.

And if you want to leave a comment on this post, use the box below. All comments need to be approved by a moderator.

Find out more about:

2 Comments

Your Opinion?
Show Comments (2 Comments)
huskerfanbb on 6/22/2013 @ 11:28am EDT Said:

As a Husker fan, I’m obviously partial to Memorial Stadium. However, we had a GREAT experience at Ohio State last year (well, except for the actual game, LOL!!!), and Wisconsin was a good stadium experience the year before (again, not the game result).

I want to go to the Big House this year.

I am a bit leery of Penn State. Sure, there are jerks at every venue, but I’ve talked to a lot of fans of opposing teams who have been to Beaver Stadium and said their experience with the fans there was really bad.

You will find VERY FEW of those jerks in Lincoln, and we really didn’t run across any in Columbus, and only a few in Madison.

Craig on 6/24/2013 @ 9:23am EDT Said:

Been to all Big Ten stadiums except Minnesota and Nebraska. Good fans and good times in all except Michigan St. For some reason their fan base thinks they have won multiple national championships recently and are so much better than everyone else. Wouldn’t go back there again if I had a ticket given to me.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Have a question for BTN Customer Service? Please e-mail us here