Debate It: 2013 Defensive Player of the Year?

Here’s what we know: There will be no repeat winner for the Nagurski-Woodson Defensive Player of the Year. Last year’s winner, John Simon, is in the NFL, leaving a pool of worthy candidates to fight for the award now in its third year. Who’s the top candidate entering the season? Tom Dienhart and Brent Yarina discuss it in this post.

Previous Nagurski-Woodson Winners
2011: Devon Still, DT, Penn State
2012: John Simon, DE, Ohio State

Tom: The preseason favorite has to be the best player off what could be the Big Ten’s best defense (sorry, Michigan State): Ohio State linebacker Ryan Shazier. We knew he was gonna be special when he made a significant impact as a true freshman in 2011. Shazier blossomed last year into a playmaker extraordinaire, showing a knack for making plays sideline-to-sideline. Shazier is a volatile mix of athletic ability and instincts. Quick note: I would have had Michigan linebacker Jake Ryan on my list below if was entering the year healthy.

Tom’s top 5 candidates:
1. Ryan Shazier, LB, Ohio State
2. Deion Barnes, DE, Penn State
3. Jonathan Brown, LB Illinois
4. Max Bullough, LB, Michigan State
5. Ra’Shede Hageman, DT, Minnesota
Dark horse: Ibraheim Campbell, S, Northwestern

[ RELATED: Who will win 2013 Graham-George Offensive Player of the Year? ]

Brent: It’s blind resume time. Player A’s stats: 45 tackles, 14.5 tackles for loss, nine sacks and one forced fumble. Player B’s stats: 42 tackles, 12.5 tackles for loss, nine sacks and three forced fumbles. After mulling over the numbers, it’s not crazy to think “Player B” had the better season, no? Well, “Player A” is 2012 Nagurski-Woodson winner John Simon, and “Player B” is Northwestern’s Tyler Scott. It’s true. Scott was one of the Big Ten’s most underrated defenders a season ago, and with much of the same faces around him, he’s certain to produce and receive more fanfare in 2013.

Brent’s top 5 candidates:
1. Tyler Scott, DE, Northwestern
2. Ryan Shazier, LB, Ohio State
3. Chris Borland, LB, Wisconsin
4. Bradley Roby, CB, Ohio State
5. Max Bullough, LB, Michigan State
Dark horse: Blake Countess, CB, Michigan

Find out more about: ,

3 Comments

Your Opinion?
Show Comments (3 Comments)
scott s on 6/19/2013 @ 9:26am EDT Said:

here what i dont get? ohio has the best of the best in every catigory def, offense, its just amazing how great they are going to be. AND THEY LOST ALL OF THERE DEF. FRONT LINE??????????????? THE BEST QB IN BIG TEN, BEST DEF. IN BIG TEN…. THEY ARE JUST GOING TO BE UNSTOPPABLE….. ACCORDING TO EVERYONE… AND THAT ABSOLUTLY BULLSHIT. SINCE WHEN ARE THEY GOING TO HAVE THE BEST DEF. IN BIG TEN>> WHAT ABOUT MSU?? AND YES MICH. PLEASE GET OFF THERE BAND WAGON.. THEY HAVE ONE PLACE TO GO AND THATS DOWN?? THEY BARELY GOT BUY SOME GAMES LAST YEAR THAT WONT HAPPEN THIS YEAR. AND BRAXTON WILL GET HURT THIS YEAR.

Josh on 6/19/2013 @ 11:35am EDT Said:

What would people talk about if they didn’t play up Ohio State and Michigan???? (Sarcasm) There’s a reason The Kardashians are huge in this country. People are sheep for good public relations and marketing. Ohio State and Michigan have that in spades. One and a half National Titles in about 40 years and yet all you hear about is those 2 schools. They have done very little to deserve it. Much like The Kardashians.

Joseph on 6/20/2013 @ 4:21am EDT Said:

Shazier or Michael Bennett.