Dienhart: O'Brien staying is the right thing

Bill O’Brien is a terrific coach. We saw that in just one season of work at Penn State. He walked into an untenable situation and promptly led a shorthanded team to an 8-4 record (6-2 Big Ten) when most forecast gloom. But, much heavy lifting remains. And O’Brien is going to be around for it.

That has the message hammered home during a press conference today at Penn State, in which O’Brien addressed a variety of issues.

On if a donor had ponied up $1.3 million to get him to stay:

“No. You can ask anyone that knows me; in 20 years of coaching, I have never asked for a raise. The last thing I’m about is money. If I was about money, I probably wouldn’t be sitting here. I never asked anybody for a raise. It gets my blood boiling when people say this is about money.”

On if he was misled about how severe looming NCAA sanctions would be upon taking the job:

“Let me set the record straight on that; I interviewed with a search committee on Skype, and then came on campus, and I asked many, many questions. It was around that time that [Penn State president] Rodney Erickson had to answer questions from the NCAA, and once we answered those we knew we’d have a better idea.

“Nobody gave me bad information; it was just no one really knew. I took a leap of faith, and Penn State took a leap of faith, and I shook their hand to become the next head coach.”

O’Brien also discussed NFL teams’ interest in him as there were reports he interviewed with the Browns and Eagles, and O’Brein said his representative did entertain interest from NFL teams. But, how serious any of the discussions got is conjecture.

Here’s the bottom line: O’Brien will be back. For how long? Who knows? But let’s just worry about today. That’s enough.

Had O’Brien left, it would have been a paralyzing blow to the Nittany Lions, who already are about to feel the full brunt of debilitating NCAA sanctions as a result of the Jerry Sandusky scandal. The most crippling? The loss of 10 initial scholarships for four years beginning in 2013-14. That will drop Penn State’s total number of scholarships from 85 to 65 for four years beginning in 2014-15.

Penn State Offense (FBS Rank)
Yards: 5015 (70)
Passing Yards: 3278 (44)
Rushing Yards: 1737 (90)
Points per game: 29.1 (63)
Yards per game: 417.9 (54)
Touchdowns: 42 (65)
Field Goals: 14 (62)

Try competing with the likes of Ohio State, Wisconsin, Michigan, Nebraska and Michigan State with those scholarship limits. It will be almost impossible. The loss of so many scholarships essentially will make the Nittany Lions a FCS program competing on the FBS level.
Sorta like having, say, Youngstown State play a full Big Ten schedule. Penn State may be able to compete from time to time. But attrition in the form of injuries and transfers likely will take a toll.

There will be many lopsided scores, many ugly losses, many hard times and many long Saturdays. But, believe me, had O’Brien left, things would have been direr.

Who would have coached Penn State? It would have been difficult to have lured someone of O’Brien’s quality from the outside. More likely, Penn State probably would have promoted from within, with the likely candidates being defensive line coach Larry Johnson, linebackers coach Ron Vanderlinden or defensive coordinator Ted Roof.

But also remember that O’Brien was the one who ran the offense and called the plays. Who would have taken over those duties? It was that offense that made Penn State special this season.

It’s all moot now with O’Brien back. But what makes having him back so delicious for Penn State is the fact his staff also is back. And, it may be the top staff in the Big Ten. There are few better than Roof, Johnson, Vanderlinden, receivers coach Stan Hixon, offensive line coach Mac McWhorter, secondary coach John Butler, quarterbacks coach Charlie Fisher, tight ends coach John Strollo and running backs coach Charles London.

Penn State Defense (FBS Rank)
Yards: 4241 (18)
Passing Yards: 2700 (38)
Rushing Yards: 1541 (18)
Points per game: 19.1 (16)
Yards per game: 353.4 (29)
Touchdowns: 25 (13)
Field Goals: 11 (24)

O’Brien and his coaches know how to practice with a short roster, as years in the NFL prepared O’Brien for working with truncated numbers. There also are a lot of wise minds—Roof, McWhorter, Johnson, Vanderlinden, Fisher. Rest assured: This group will maximize the talent on hand—no matter how limited. They also will develop a strong walk-on program built on the bedrock Pennsylvania kids.

Their pitch: Come be part of something more special than a championship or bowl game at Penn State. Come be part of rebuilding one of college football’s great brands.

And, it’s an authentic sales pitch coming from O’Brien. His actions speak louder than words. Recruits see his commitment. Why not give theirs?

In this day and age, we see “loyalty” uttered often by coaches, but it’s rarely acted upon. Well, O’Brien is an exception. He did the right thing, pledging his allegiance to a sickly Penn State program that many would have turned their backs on in lieu of NFL glory and millions.

O’Brien knows he can be part of something greater than a national championship, Big Ten crown or fat bank account. And, his actions are showing that. He can be part of the rebuilding of one of the greatest programs in college football history. Kids can’t deny that.
No matter how the next four or so years go, O’Brien’s name never will be forgotten in bucolic State College, Pa. And his willingness to stand by the school’s side during these coming dark days will mean as much as anything that went on at Beaver Stadium in the previous 50 years.

About Tom Dienhart BTN.com senior writer Tom Dienhart is a veteran sports journalist who covers Big Ten football and men’s basketball for BTN.com and BTN TV. Find him on Twitter and Facebook, read all of his work at btn.com/tomdienhart, and subscribe to his posts via RSS. Also, send questions to his weekly mailbag using the form below and read all of his previous answers in his reader mailbag section.

And if you want to leave a comment on this post, use the box below. All comments need to be approved by a moderator.


Your Opinion?
Show Comments (4 Comments)
Mark Charles Peshaba on 1/7/2013 @ 1:29pm EDT Said:

Heck yes O’brien staying is the right thing.
Besides Urban Meyer, O’brien is one of two of the best coaches the B1G conference has got.
Definetly a National Championship contender some day.
I would like to see more coaches like O’brien in our conference.
First year and he does an impressive 8-4. Wait til he gets the recruits he wants and PSU gets out from under sanctions and look out!!!!!

bob jones on 1/7/2013 @ 2:55pm EDT Said:

Nice to see a coach stick around and honor his commitment and not go running off as soon as someone offers more money. The coach obviously did a tremendous job this year and will have his work cut out for him with all of the sanctions. Nice job Coach O’Brien and good luck.

S. Artz on 1/7/2013 @ 7:38pm EDT Said:

My first “blog contribution” I wasn’t sure where else to post it – please indulge.

This has to do with B1G expansion and my idea of how to “division” football within the conference. I suspect you will see the B1G at 16 members in the near future. The thought of having two divisions of eight teams each does not excite me. Too many years will pass until you play all the teams. Following is my recommendation.

You create four divisions of four teams each, for now labeled division A, B, C & D. Every team has a cross divisional rivalry from each of the other three divisions. These cross divisional rivalries will play each other every year. To continue, I will draft a schedule using the above “A,B,C,D” divisions. The first year divisions A & B play each other as will C&D, add the two remaining cross divisional rivalry games and you have a nine game conference schedule. The second year divisions A & C will be matched up as will B & D. And in year three A &D will play each other as will C & B. Regarding the championship game, you treat the division matchups as a division. So in year one the best record (“winner”) of the A & B matchup will play the best from the C & D matchup. In year two the championship game will be between the “winner of the A&C versus the winner of the B&D matchup and so on. This schedule guarantees no more than two years pass without playing every team in the league, it creates a nine game conference schedule and provides numerous opportunity to maintain long standing rivalries.

Thanks for your time.

Eric Kipker on 1/11/2013 @ 2:48pm EDT Said:

I was surprised to hear Bill state that his no 1 objective was to have the best football program. I would think that since he works at an educational institution that his number one priority would be to make sure all or as many as possible of his players receive an an education and graduate.

And the way he bragged about being contacted by the NFL. I never realized that he was such an egomaniac.