Tom's Top 10: Would OSU beat other perfect teams?

Another week is in the books. The AP and Coaches polls are out. Now, it’s time to release my Top 10 for the week. Here’s a look at the good, the bad and the whatever-the-heck-I-feel-like-looking-at as I glance back on Saturday from my Sunday perch.

1. Is there a more thrilling team in the nation than Nebraska? In fact, it is No. 1 on the Cardiac Poll. The Cornhuskers are making a habit of rallying for thrilling wins. There was a 17-point comeback vs. Wisconsin; a 12-point comeback at Northwestern; a 10-point comeback at Michigan State. Keep those digitalis handy, Herbie.

2. And Nebraska’s run of three wins in a row is all the more remarkable when you remember that stud running back Rex Burkhead has played in just five games this season because of a knee injury and has only 405 yards. Ameer Abdullah has been a revelation as his replacement, keeping the ground game going for the Cornhuskers with 826 yards rushing and eight touchdowns.

[RELATED: Dienhart: "This looks like it will be Nebraska's year"]

3. OK, let’s concede Ohio State’s Braxton Miller is the top quarterback in the Big Ten. The real fun issue: Who is second best? Penn State’s Matt McGloin or Nebraska’s Taylor Martinez? The two will meet next Saturday in Lincoln.

4. How many of these unbeaten teams do you think Ohio State could beat? Alabama? Notre Dame? Oregon? Kansas State? I’m not sure if the Buckeyes could beat any of them, but I think the Buckeyes would have a decent shot vs. the Irish and Wildcats. The Crimson Tide? The Ducks? Not so much so.

5. Did we all rush to judgment and say that Penn State’s Bill O’Brien should be Big Ten Coach of the Year? Perhaps we should pause and give more consideration to Indiana’s Kevin Wilson, especially if he pulls off a win vs. Wisconsin this Saturday in what looks like the biggest game in Bloomington since the Hoosiers capped the 2007 season with a victory vs. Purdue to earn a bowl bid for the memory of Terry Hoeppner.

[RELATED: Dienhart: 5 things I learned in Week 10]

6. Who else thought Michigan State would be 5-5 through 10 games? That’s exactly what I thought. I had the Spartans not just winning the Legends—but winning the Big Ten. Alas, Michigan State will maintain its seat next to other Big Ten teams that have yet to play in a BCS bowl (1998 to date)—Minnesota, Indiana and Northwestern.

7. With each successive Ohio State win, I recall how the Buckeyes had the choice last season to play in that Gator Bowl vs. Florida or take a bowl ban in 2011 and then play in one this season. If not for that fateful decision last season, this year’s Ohio State team would be primed for a Rose Bowl berth—and perhaps more.

8. I’m not sure if Purdue or Illinois will win another game. Oops, that’s right: These two struggling teams will meet in Champaign on Nov. 17. As it stands, the Boilermakers have lost five in a row, and the Fighting Illini have lost six in a row and already are eliminated from bowl eligibility. I thought each program would be a dark horse this season. Boy, was I wrong. Really wrong.

[RELATED: See who took home Week 10 Game Balls]

9. Speaking of struggling teams, Iowa may also have issues getting bowl eligible. The Hawkeyes have four wins with games left vs. Purdue, at Michigan and vs. Nebraska. How much has Iowa struggled? Two of Iowa’s three FBS wins have come by a combined four points.

10. Wisconsin’s run back to the Big Ten title game may not be such a sure thing. The Badgers are a bit of an unknown with quarterback Joel Stave out with injury. Wisconsin has games left at Indiana, vs. Ohio State and at Penn State. This could be interesting.

BTN.com senior writer Tom Dienhart is a veteran sports journalist who covers Big Ten football and men’s basketball for BTN.com and BTN TV. Find him on Twitter and Facebook, read all of his work at btn.com/tomdienhart, and subscribe to his posts via RSS. Also, send questions to his weekly mailbag using the form below and read all of his previous answers in his reader mailbag section.

And if you want to leave a comment on this post, use the box below. All comments need to be approved by a moderator.

Find out more about:

3 Comments

Your Opinion?
Show Comments (3 Comments)
bob jones on 11/4/2012 @ 2:27pm EDT Said:

Really a shame that at the end of a great career, a great young man like Rex Burkhead would miss so much of his final season. Hopefully he gets back for the last 2 or 3 games. What a pleasure it has been to have him here at Nebraska.

Kevin on 11/4/2012 @ 4:20pm EDT Said:

Yep, it really does suck. He seems like such a nice guy too. It seems like he has “The Luck of Robbie Hummel”. He should have a great NFL career. One of the Purdue fans commented a couple weeks ago that when Purdue flagrantly flung Braxton Miller to the ground that us Ohio State Buckeye fans cheer when someone gets hurt. I think that’s the dumbest comment I’ve ever heard and I’ve heard some real dumb comments on the “Binders Full of Women” group on Facebook.

dja.ohio on 11/4/2012 @ 4:33pm EDT Said:

You can’t automatically assume the NCAA wouldn’t have imposed an additional 1 year post-season ban had tOSU elected to stay home in 2011.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Have a question for BTN Customer Service? Please e-mail us here