Debate it: Best RB not named Le'Veon Bell is ...

When talking best running back in the Big Ten, BTN.com’s Tom Dienhart and Brent Yarina agree it’s Le’Veon Bell. Through five games, Bell leads Big Ten backs in yards (655 – yes, he also has most carries) and ranks in the top two in receptions (20) and receiving yards (125). He’s also a terrific blocker.

In other words, Bell’s a complete back. It’s the Big Ten’s No. 2 back where our guys disagree. They debate it in this post, plus we include your tweets.

Brent: My guy is Northwestern’s Venric Mark. He’s the top running back in my latest Player Rankings, a more week-to-week, what-have-you-done-for-me-lately thing, so the diminutive, electric Wildcat has to be my answer here.

Tom: Mark is an electric back with big-play ability. But I have to go with Iowa wunderkind Mark Weisman, who is one of the feel-good stories in college football this season. And Brent—I never in a million years thought any Hawkeye back would be in this conversation—let along leading it–back on Labor Day.

[RELATED: Week 6 Power Rankings | Week 6 Player Rankings | Week 6 Heisman Watch]

Brent: Interesting that neither of us went Montee Ball or Rex Burkhead. Guess we have injuries to thank for that. You’re right, though, Weisman is the best story in the Big Ten. His stiff-arm is out of this world, and I can watch the replays of it all day long. But I like Mark because he’s so exciting – not to mention productive – and he should benefit the more Northwestern runs do-it-all Kain Colter, as it did last week.

Tom: Weisman is a tribute to the old “luck” equation: preparation meets opportunity. And what makes the sophomore walk-on’s feats all the more incredible is he’s doing them without much help from the passing game and behind a line with three new starters. This is storybook stuff, Brent. Someone call Hollywood!!

Brent: Ha! It definitely is. It’s up there with Blair White, the hopeful dentist, and J.J. Watt, the former pizza delivery boy, when it comes to Big Ten walk-on stories. Mark is a good story, too. He added mass this offseason and changed positions, and he hasn’t shown any signs of a guy making such an adjustment.

Mark Weisman
US PRESSWIRE

Tom: Yes, I like Mark, too, but I still wonder if at 5-8, 175, how well he can hold up. Is he really a feature back? Quarterback Kain Colter means as much—if not more—to Northwestern’s rush game. Still, Mark is a special guy in the open field and a big play waiting to happen. This just isn’t a great year for running backs in the Big Ten.

Brent: Size and durability are issues. But until they start to affect Mark, it’s unfair to hold that against him. One can make the same argument for Weisman, as well. I mean, neither of us know how he’ll hold up to all of these carries. He’s a big guy, no doubt, but is he accustom to toting the rock THIS much?

Tom: Yes, Weisman isn’t a proven commodity over the long haul. But he is a 6-0, 225 pound fullback by trade. So, you’d figure he can take a licking. But, as other Hawkeye backs get healthy—guys like Damon Bullock and Greg Garmon—I have to think Weisman’s role could be reduced. Still, he is fun to watch and a great story.

Brent: Indeed. So we both went with a guy who has “Mark” in his name. Both are good options, but I’m sure BTN.com fans will be quick to make a case for for Ball and Burkhead.

Big Ten Rushing Leaders
Rank Player Team G Rushes Yds Yds/G Avg TD Long
1 L. Bell MSU 5 134 655 131.0 4.9 5 40
2 B. Miller OhioSt 5 90 577 115.4 6.4 7 65
3 V. Mark NW 5 101 538 107.6 5.3 5 47
4 M. Weisman Iowa 5 74 515 103.0 7.0 7 44
5 A. Abdullah Neb 5 79 486 97.2 6.2 5 45
6 M. Ball Wisc 5 125 450 90.0 3.6 6 22
7 D. Robinson Mich 4 66 441 110.3 6.7 4 79
8 D. Kirkwood Minn 5 93 394 78.8 4.2 3 26
9 K. Colter NW 5 59 371 74.2 6.3 6 29
10 T. Martinez Neb 5 50 298 59.6 6.0 3 92

What do BTN.com fans think? Here are their tweets:

Find out more about:

6 Comments

Your Opinion?
Show Comments (6 Comments)
Ed Crawford on 10/4/2012 @ 3:18pm EDT Said:

In two weeks we will see both Bell and Weisman on the same field. Hope Weisman runs it down their throats .

bob jones on 10/4/2012 @ 4:23pm EDT Said:

I think the Big Ten’ best running back is either Rex Abdullah or Ameer Burkhead. They are interchangeable. They make a very strong combo and throw in Braylon Heard and true frosh Imani Cross and you have the conference’s best running attack.

Doug on 10/4/2012 @ 8:38pm EDT Said:

Hey Ed, Bell is gonna run it down Iowa’s throats

Rhonda on 10/5/2012 @ 1:05am EDT Said:

I like the Hawkeye running back, Weisman. He makes watching Big Ten football exciting.

GRIFFINHAWK on 10/5/2012 @ 8:05pm EDT Said:

Let’s take a realistic look at team scenaros, preseason expectations and stats. Iowa has been suspect thus far in their offensive performance. AIRBHG transfers, leads Rb to law enforcement or strikes down the poor student/athlete with ligement damage that takes them out of action for the year. Enter Mark Weisman. Not even on the radar. Walk on. He runs over people providing one bright spot in an otherwise pretty dismal offense. Hmm, other RB referenced here were three, four, or five star recruits (oh, yeah, ON SCHOLARSHIP). Think about it!

Doug on 10/6/2012 @ 9:43am EDT Said:

Bell was only a 2 star recruit….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Have a question for BTN Customer Service? Please e-mail us here